Invocation of International (Treaty) Law Principles Against an Aggressor State: Suspension, Restriction of Membership Rights, Expulsion?

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.18523/kmlpj320035.2024-10.19-50

Keywords:

Pacta Sunt Servanda, Bona Fide, Jus Cogens, Rule of Law, Russia’s Isolation, Aggression against Ukraine, United Nations

Abstract

The research aims at the invocation of the main principles of international law and treaty law, in particular, pacta sunt servanda, bona fide, jus cogens and the rule of law, in order to support the right to suspend, limit or restrict membership rights of Russia in treaties and international organizations in the context of aggression against Ukraine. The authors seek to demonstrate that the principles allow for certain measures to be taken against a State manifestly and flagrantly violating international law and to present this principle-based reasoning with a reference to the United Nations and the UN Charter. The contents of the listed principles are revealed demonstrating that they contain specific countermeasures regarding treaty participation and organization membership that may be invoked against the aggressor State. The authors emphasize that international law has always evolved around unprecedented events following universal legal values, and aggression against Ukraine obliges members of the international community to undertake responsibility and use international law solutions, including invocation of international (treaty) law principles in order the aggressor State does not benefit from grave breaches of international law and progressive development of international law is being ensured.

Author Biographies

Indrė Isokaitė-Valužė, Vilnius University

Indrė Isokaitė-Valužė holds a degree of social sciences (law), is an associate professor at the Law Faculty of Vilnius University, member of the Public Law Department. She is also an adviser to the Dean for International Development and the Head of the Ukrainian Law Centre of the Law Faculty of Vilnius University, member of the Senate of Vilnius University.

Gabija Grigaitė-Daugirdė, Vilnius University; Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania

Gabija Grigaitė-Daugirdė holds a degree of social sciences (law), is a senior lecturer at the Law Faculty of Vilnius University, member of the Public Law Department. She is a Vice-Minister of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania.

References

  1. Alden, R. “South Africa is Rebuffed by U.N., but Not Expelled,” The New York Times, announced October 6, 1973, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.nytimes.com/1973/10/06/archives/south-africa-is-rebuffed-by-un-but-notexpelled-south-africa.html.
  2. Amirfar, C., Zamour, R., Pickard, D. (2022). “Representation of Member States at the United Nations: Recent Challenges,” American Society of International Law, Asil Insights, Vol. 26, Issue 6, www.asil.org/insights/volume/26/issue/6.
  3. Aust, A. (2013). Modern Treaty Law and Practice (Third Edition). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
  4. Briefing of the European Parliament on suspension and expulsion of states from international organisations. Analysis of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties and of the practice at the United Nations and the Council of Europe, July 2023, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/BRIE/2023/751410/EPRS_BRI(2023)751410_EN.pdf.
  5. Butchard, P. (2024). Conflict in Ukraine: A Special Tribunal on the Crime of Aggression. House of Commons Library, announced February 22, 2024, accessed June 20, 2024: https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-9968/CBP-9968.pdf.
  6. Cançado Trindade, A. A. (2006). International Law for Humankind: Towards a New Ius Gentium. Hague: Hague Academy of International Law.
  7. Carswell, A. J. (2013). “Unblocking the UN Security Council: The Uniting for Peace Resolution,” Journal of Conflict and Security Law, Volume 18, Issue 3, p. 453-480.
  8. Consultative Council of European Prosecutors (CCPE). “Exclusion of the Russian Federation from the Council of Europe and suspension of all relations with Belarus,” announced March 17, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, www.coe.int/en/web/ccpe/-/the-russian-federation-isexcluded-from-the-council-of-europe.
  9. Council of Europe. “Agreements establishing the Commonwealth of Independent States,” 1991, accessed June 28, 2024, www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL(1994)054-e.
  10. Council of Europe. Reykjavík Declaration. 4th Summit of Heads of State and Government of the Council of Europe, May 16-17, 2023, accessed 28 June 2024, https://edoc.coe.int/en/thecouncil-of-europe-in-brief/11619-united-around-our-values-reykjavik-declaration.html.
  11. Council of the European Union. “EU Sanctions against Russia explained,” accessed June 20, 2024, www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/sanctions-against-russia/sanctions-againstrussia-explained/.
  12. DeLisle, J., Glaser S., B. Why UN General Assembly Resolution 2758 Does Not Establish Beijing’s “One China” Principle: A Legal Perspective, April 2024, accessed June 28, 2024, www.gmfus.org/sites/default/files/2024-04/GMF_UNGA%20Res.%202758_April%202024%20Report.pdf.
  13. Detsch, J., Gramer, R. “Helsinki Commission Recommends Kicking Russia Off U.N. Security Council. Not so fast, experts say,” October 13, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/10/13/helsinki-commission-recommends-kicking-russia-offu-n-security-council/.
  14. Dissenting opinion of President Winiarski to the ICJ Advisory Opinion of July 20, 1962 on Certain expenses of the United Nations, I.C.J. Reports 1962, p. 151.
  15. Dzehtsiarou, K., Coffey, D. K. (2019). Suspension and Expulsion of Members of the Council of Europe: Difficult Decisions in Troubled Times, International and Comparative Law Quarterly, Vol. 68(2), p. 443-476. doi:10.1017/S0020589319000101.
  16. European Parliament resolution of November 23, 2022 on recognizing the Russian Federation as a state sponsor of terrorism (2022/2896(RSP)), (2023/C 167/03).
  17. “Germany says will intervene at The Hague on Israel’s behalf, blasts genocide charge,” the Times of Israel, accessed June 28, 2024, www.timesofisrael.com/germany-says-will-interveneat-the-hague-on-israels-behalf-blasts-genocide-charge/.
  18. Grant, D. T. “Expelling Russia from the UN Security Council – a How-to Guide,” The Centre for European Policy Analysis (CEPA), announced September 26, 2022, accessed June 20, 2024, https://cepa.org/article/expelling-russia-from-the-un-security-council-a-how-to-guide/.
  19. Grant, T. “No, Russia Can (Still) Not be Removed from the UN Security Council: A Response to Thomas Grant and Others: Part Two,” announced February 11, 2023, accessed June 28, 2024, https://opiniojuris.org/2023/02/11/no-russia-can-still-not-be-removed-from-the-unsecurity-council-a-response-to-thomas-grant-and-others-part-two/.
  20. Gross, L. (1945). Was the Soviet Union Expelled from the League of Nations? American Journal of International Law, Vol. 39(1), p. 35-44.
  21. Halberstam, M. (1984). Excluding Israel from the General Assembly by a Rejection of its Credentials, AJIL, Vol. 78.
  22. Higgins, R. (1963). The Development of International Law Through Political Organs of the United Nations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
  23. ICJ Advisory Opinion of July 20, 1962 on Certain expenses of the United Nations, I.C.J. Reports 1962, p. 151.
  24. ICJ Judgment of 2024 in Allegations of Genocide under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russian Federation: 32 States intervening), accessed June 28, 2024, www.icj-cij.org/sites/default/files/caserelated/182/182-20240202-jud-01-00-en.pdf.
  25. ICJ Judgment of December 20, 1974 in Nuclear Tests (Australia v. France), I.C.J. Reports 1974, p. 253.
  26. ICJ Judgment of September 25, 1997 in Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary v. Slovakia), I.C.J. Reports 1997, p. 7.
  27. ICJ Order of 16 March 2022 in the Allegations of Genocide under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russian Federation), Provisional Measures, I.C.J. Reports 2022, p. 211.
  28. ICJ. The case concerning Allegations of Genocide under the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Ukraine v. Russian Federation) with 32 States intervening, accessed June 20, 2024: https://www.icj-cij.org/case/182/intervention.
  29. “Isolation. Russia ousted from 42 international fora,” announced June 2, 2022, accessed June 20, 2024, https://war.ukraine.ua/articles/isolation-russia-suspended-from-42-international-platforms/.
  30. International Law Commission. Chapter V: Peremptory norms of general international law (jus cogens). Report of the International Law Commission: Seventy-first session (29 April – 7 June and 8 July – 9 August 2019).
  31. International Law Commission. Draft Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, with commentaries 2001, Yearbook of the International Law Commission, 2001, vol. II, Part Two.
  32. International Law Commission. Draft articles on the effects of armed conflicts on treaties, with commentaries, Yearbook of the International Law Commission, 2011, Vol. 2, part II.
  33. Isokaitė-Valužė, I., Šinkūnas, H. (2023). Pamatinės teisės idėjos kaip bendrieji teisės principai ir konstituciniai principai [Fundamental Ideas of Law as General Principles of Law and Constitutional Principles]. In Konstitucinė justicija Lietuvoje: trys veiklos dešimtmečiai [Constitutional Justice in Lithuania: Three Decades of Activity]. Vilnius: Vilniaus universiteto leidykla, p. 446-465.
  34. Jhabvala, F. (1977) The Credentials Approach to Representation Questions in the U.N. General Assembly. California Western International Law Journal, Vol. 7, No. 3, p. 615-638, accessed June 28, 2024, https://scholarlycommons.law.cwsl.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1834&context=cwilj.
  35. Kelsen, H. (1954). Collective Security under International Law. International Law Studies, Naval War College.
  36. Kliuchkovskyi, M. “How the Register of Damage Caused by Russia's Aggression will work,” European Pravda, April 2, 2024, accessed June 20, 2024: www.eurointegration.com.ua/eng/articles/2024/04/2/7182873/.
  37. Lampert, A. “Russia loses U.N. aviation council seat in rebuke”, Reuters, announced October 1, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, www.reuters.com/world/europe/russia-not-reelected-un-aviation-agencys-36-member-council-2022-10-01/.
  38. “Lithuania to terminate several agreements with Russia, Belarus,” BNS, Lrt.lt, announced May 22, 2024, accessed June 28, 2024, www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/2279450/lithuaniato-terminate-several-agreements-with-russia-belarus.
  39. Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Lithuania. “G. Grigaitė-Daugirdė: we must make the aggressor pays provision a reality,” announced July 25, 2022, accessed June 20, 2024, https://tm.lrv.lt/en/news/g-grigaite-daugirde-we-must-make-the-aggressor-pays-provision-areality/.
  40. National broadcaster of Lithuania. “OSCE not sending observers to Lithuania’s election due to Vilnius’ conditions,” lrt.lt, announced May 8, 2024, accessed June 20, 2024, www.lrt.lt/en/news-in-english/19/2267833/osce-not-sending-observers-to-lithuania-selection-due-to-vilnius-conditions.
  41. Nichols, M. (2022). Afghan Taliban administration, Myanmar junta not allowed into United Nations for now, 15 December, 2022, accessed June 29, 2024, https://www.reuters.com/world/afghan-taliban-administration-myanmar-junta-not-allowedinto-united-nations-now-2022-12-15/.
  42. Official Website of the President of Ukraine. “We Do Not Want the UN Charter to Be Burnt Down Just Like These Books – Address by the President of Ukraine to the World Leaders on the Eve of the Peace Summit,” May 26, 2024, accessed June 20, 2024, www.president.gov.ua/en/news/mi-ne-hochemo-shob-tak-samo-yak-ci-knizhki-zgoriv-statutoon-91137.
  43. Ostrof, C. “Russia Suspended from Bank for International Settlements.” The Wall Street Journal, March 11, 2022, accessed 28 June 2024, www.wsj.com/livecoverage/russia-ukrainelatest-news-2022-03-11/card/russia-suspended-from-bank-for-international-settlementsgEiXwjyiIlkp9jSTV7sU.
  44. Robert H. Jackson Center. Opening Statement before the International Military Tribunal. “Second Day, Wednesday, 11/21/1945, Part 04,” in Trial of the Major War Criminals before the International Military Tribunal. Volume II. Proceedings: 11/14/1945-11/30/1945. [Official text in the English language.] Nuremberg: IMT, 1947, p. 98-102, accessed June 28, 2024, www.roberthjackson.org/speecah-and-writing/opening-statement-before-the-internationalmilitary-tribunal/.
  45. Rules of Procedures of the General Assembly, A/520/Rev.20, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.un.org/en/ga/about/ropga/pdf/A_520_Rev.20.pdf.
  46. “Russia’s parliament to vote on suspending Moscow's participation in OSCE Parliamentary Assembly,” Reuters, announced February 14, 2024, accessed 20 June 2024, www.reuters.com/world/europe/russias-parliament-vote-suspending-moscows-osceparticipation-2024-02-13/.
  47. “Russia suspended from Council of the Baltic Sea States,” announced March 3, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, www.regjeringen.no/en/aktuelt/russland-suspenderes-fraostersjoradet/id2903009/.
  48. “Russia suspended from International Council for the Exploration of the Seas,” updated March 30, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, www.intrafish.com/fisheries/russia-suspended-frominternational-council-for-the-exploration-of-the-seas/2-1-1193597?zephr_sso_ott=wJ6CZk.
  49. Samus, M., Solovian, V. “Development of a Possible Mechanism for Exclusion of Russia from the UN Security Council and IAEA,” Analytical Portal New Geopolitics Research Network, accessed June 20, 2024, https://analytics.intsecurity.org/en/mechanism-exclusion-russia-unsecurity-council-iaea/.
  50. Scharf, M. S. Power Shift: The Return of the Uniting for Peace Resolution, Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law, 2023, Vol. 55, Issue 1.
  51. Separate Opinion of Judge Sir Gerald Fitzmaurice, the ICJ Advisory Opinion of July 20, 1962 on Certain expenses of the United Nations, I.C.J. Reports 1962, p. 151.
  52. “Statement from OECD Secretary-General on further measures in response to Russia’s large-scale aggression against Ukraine – OECD,” accessed June 28, 2024, https://search.oecd.org/countries/russia/statement-from-the-oecd-council-on-furthermeasures-in-response-to-russia-s-large-scale-aggression-against-ukraine.htm.
  53. Suttner, R. (1984). Has South Africa Been Illegally Excluded from the United Nations General Assembly? African Journal of International and Comparative Law, Vol. 17, p. 279-301.
  54. Tamada, D. (2024). War in Ukraine and Implications for International Investment Law. International Community Law Review, 26(1-2), p. 187-207. https://doi.org/10.1163/18719732-12341499.
  55. “The Council of Europe at a Glance,” accessed June 20, 2024, www.coe.int/en/web/portal/the-council-of-europe-at-a-glance.
  56. Ukraine believes Russia’s UN, UNSC membership illegitimate, announced February 25, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, https://euromaidanpress.com/2022/02/25/ukraine-questionslegality-of-russias-un-unsc-membership/.
  57. The United Nations Charter. 1945, 1 UNTS XVI, United Nations Charter (full text), accessed June 20, 2024, www.un.org/en/about-us/un-charter/full-text.
  58. “Ukraine President Zelensky addresses United Nations Security Council,” April 5, 2022, video accessed June 20, 2024, www.youtube.com/watch?v=ytPWmYEIa78.
  59. UN General Assembly Resolution 377 (V), Uniting for Peace of November 3, 1950.
  60. UN General Assembly resolution 396(V) (1950) of December 14, 1950, on Recognition by the United Nations of the representation of a Member State, accessed June 28, 2024, www.refworld.org/legal/resolution/unga/1950/en/7705.
  61. UN General Assembly Resolution of November 6, 1962 adopted in the 17th session, accessed June 20, 2024, www.worldlii.org/int/other/UNGA/1962/21.pdf.
  62. UN General Assembly Resolution of April 7, 2022, A/RES/ES-11/3, accessed June 28, 2024, www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es-11_3.pdf.
  63. UN General Assembly Resolution of March 2, 2022, A/RES/ES-11/1, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es-11_1.pdf.
  64. UN General Assembly Resolution of March 2, 2023, A/RES/ES-11/6, accessed June 28, 2024, www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es_11_6.pdf.
  65. UN General Assembly Resolution of March 24, 2022, A/RES/ES-11/2, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es-11_2.pdf.
  66. UN General Assembly Resolution of November 14, 2022, A/RES/ES-11/5, accessed June 28, 2024, https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es_11_5.pdf.
  67. UN General Assembly Resolution of October 12, 2022, A/RES/ES-11/4, accessed June 28, 2024, www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/a_res_es_11_4.pdf.
  68. UN General Assembly resolution of December 15, 1970 on Declaration on principles of international law concerning friendly relations and co-operation among States in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations, https://treaties.un.org/doc/source/docs/A_RES_2625-Eng.pdf.
  69. United Nations, Office on Genocide Prevention and the Responsibility to Protect, accessed June 20, 2024, www.un.org/en/genocideprevention/about-responsibility-to-protect.shtml.
  70. United Nations. “After Much Wrangling, General Assembly Seats National Transitional Council of Libya as Country’s Representative for Sixty-Sixth Session,” General Assembly press release, September 16, 2011.
  71. United Nations. “General Assembly Overwhelmingly Adopts Resolution Demanding Russian Federation Immediately End Illegal Use of Force in Ukraine, Withdraw All Troops,” UN Meetings Coverage and Press Releases of March 2, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, https://press.un.org/en/2022/ga12407.doc.htm.
  72. United Nations. “New vision of the Secretary-General for the Rule of Law,” accessed June 20, 2024, www.un.org/ruleoflaw/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/New-Vision-of-the-Secretary-General-for-the-Rule-of-Law.pdf.
  73. United Nations. “Russian Federation.” Member States, accessed June 28, 2024, www.un.org/en/about-us/member-states/russian-federation.
  74. United Nations. “Security Council Fails to Adopt Draft Resolution on Ending Ukraine Crisis, as Russian Federation Wields Veto,” UN Meetings Coverage and Press Releases of February 25, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, https://press.un.org/en/2022/sc14808.doc.htm.
  75. United Nations. “UN General Assembly votes to suspend Russia from the Human Rights Council,” announced April 7, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, https://news.un.org/en/story/2022/04/1115782.
  76. United Nations. “United Nations and the Rule of Law.” What is the Rule of Law, accessed June 20, 2024, www.un.org/ruleoflaw/what-is-the-rule-of-law/.
  77. Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties of 1969. United Nations Treaty Series, Vol. 1155.
  78. “World Tourism Organization (UNWTO) Members Vote to Suspend Russia,” announced April 27, 2022, accessed June 28, 2024, www.unwto.org/ar/node/12876.
  79. Zaverukha, I. “Op-Ed: The U.N. should kick Russia off the Security Council,” Los Angeles Times, announced March 3, 2022, accessed 20 June 2024, www.latimes.com/opinion/story/2022-03-03/united-nations-should-remove-russia-from-thesecurity-council.
  80. “Zelensky tells UN that Russia must be expelled from Security Council,” France24, modified April 5, 2022, accessed June 20, 2024, www.france24.com/en/europe/20220405-live-ukraines-zelensky-to-address-security-council-amid-outrage-over-bucha-killings.

Downloads

Published

2024-12-30

How to Cite

Isokaitė-Valužė, I., & Grigaitė-Daugirdė, G. (2024). Invocation of International (Treaty) Law Principles Against an Aggressor State: Suspension, Restriction of Membership Rights, Expulsion?. Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal, (10), 19–50. https://doi.org/10.18523/kmlpj320035.2024-10.19-50

Issue

No. 10 (2024): Kyiv-Mohyla Law & Politics Journal

Section

Articles

License

Copyright (c) 2024 Indrė Isokaitė-Valužė, Gabija Grigaitė-Daugirdė

Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal provides free access to original research without restriction barriers (i.e. subscription fees, licensing fees etc.).

Unless otherwise indicated, content is licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) license, which means you are free to:

distribute, remix, tweak, and build upon your work, even commercially

...provided that any use is made with attribution to author(s) and Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal.

The copyright in the article or any other submission to Kyiv-Mohyla Law and Politics Journal shall remain with the author(s).

The journal allows the author(s) to hold the copyright without restrictions and will retain publishing rights without restrictions.